Comparing Impact Windows vs. Shutters vs. Mesh for Home Protection

side by side comparing security impact windows , shutters, and mesh protection against hurricanes

08.08.2023 pros and cons on each product and which will work better for you

When it comes to safeguarding your home against the unpredictable forces of nature, three popular options stand out: Impact Windows, Shutters, and Mesh. Each of these solutions offers a unique set of advantages and considerations. In this blog, we'll delve into the pros and cons of each, helping you make an informed decision about the best choice for your home protection needs.

Impact Windows:

Impact windows, also known as hurricane windows, are specially designed to withstand high-velocity winds and flying debris during storms. These windows are constructed using multiple layers of glass and advanced framing materials, making them highly durable and impact-resistant.


  1. All-around Protection: Impact windows provide continuous protection without the need for additional setup or storage.
  2. Energy Efficiency: These windows often come with energy-efficient features, such as UV protection and improved insulation.
  3. Aesthetic Appeal: Impact windows blend seamlessly with your home's design, offering an attractive and modern appearance.
  4. Noise Reduction: The multi-layer construction of impact windows can significantly reduce outdoor noise.


  1. Cost: Impact windows can be more expensive upfront, including installation costs.
  2. Limited Ventilation: These windows may offer limited opportunities for natural ventilation due to their fixed nature.


Shutters are a traditional method of protecting windows and openings during storms. They come in various materials, including wood, metal, and composite, providing both aesthetic appeal and storm protection.


  1. Customization: Shutters come in a variety of styles, colors, and materials, allowing you to match them with your home's architecture.
  2. Affordability: Depending on the material, shutters can be more cost-effective than impact windows.
  3. Ventilation Control: Shutters can be adjusted to allow for controlled ventilation when not used for storm protection.


  1. Preparation Time: Installing shutters requires manual effort before a storm, which might not be feasible for everyone.
  2. Storage Space: When not in use, shutters require storage space, which could be limited in some homes.
  3. Maintenance: Depending on the material, shutters may require regular maintenance and repainting.

Mesh Shutters

Mesh shutters, often referred to as storm screens or hurricane fabric, are lightweight and flexible materials that can be attached to windows and openings. They are designed to withstand debris impact and strong winds.


  1. Ease of Installation: Mesh screens are relatively easy to install, requiring minimal time and effort.
  2. Compact Storage: These screens can be rolled up and stored in a compact space when not in use.
  3. Affordability: Mesh screens can be more budget-friendly compared to impact windows or shutters.


  1. Durability: While designed to be durable, mesh screens might not provide the same level of impact resistance as impact windows or shutters.
  2. Aesthetic Impact: Mesh screens might not contribute to the overall aesthetics of your home as effectively as impact windows or shutters.
  3. Limited Longevity: The lifespan of mesh screens might be shorter compared to other protection methods.


Choosing between Impact Windows, Shutters, and Mesh screens ultimately depends on your budget, priorities, and specific needs. Impact windows provide continuous protection and energy efficiency, while shutters offer customization and ventilation control. Mesh screens are a cost-effective and convenient option. Assess your home's requirements and consider consulting with a professional to make the best decision for your home protection strategy.